What Is Tracking Error: A Comprehensive Explanation

A compass veering off its path

Welcome to our comprehensive guide on tracking error, an important concept in the world of finance. In this article, we will delve into the basics of tracking error, discuss its components, explore various methods to calculate it, analyze its impact on investment strategies, and provide insights on mitigating the associated risks. So, let’s get started!

Understanding the Basics of Tracking Error

When it comes to investing, one of the key concepts that investors need to grasp is tracking error. This term refers to the discrepancy between the returns of an investment portfolio and the benchmark that it aims to replicate or outperform. In other words, tracking error measures how closely the portfolio’s performance matches the performance of the benchmark.

But what does this really mean? Let’s break it down into simpler terms. Imagine you have invested in a mutual fund that aims to replicate the S&P 500 index. The S&P 500 is widely regarded as a benchmark for the overall performance of the U.S. stock market. Now, if the mutual fund’s returns perfectly match the returns of the S&P 500, then the tracking error would be zero. However, in reality, it is highly unlikely for a portfolio to perfectly replicate the benchmark’s returns.

So why is tracking error important for investors? Well, it carries significant implications for their investment decisions. By analyzing tracking error, investors can gauge the level of risk associated with their investment portfolio. A low tracking error suggests that the portfolio closely follows the benchmark, indicating a higher level of passive investing. This means that the portfolio is designed to mimic the benchmark’s performance rather than trying to outperform it. On the other hand, a high tracking error implies a greater degree of active management and potentially higher returns. This means that the portfolio manager is actively making investment decisions that may deviate from the benchmark in order to achieve better performance.

Moreover, tracking error provides valuable insights into the efficiency of an investment strategy. A consistently high tracking error may indicate that the strategy is not effectively delivering the desired results. It could suggest that the portfolio manager’s investment decisions are not aligning with the investor’s objectives or that the portfolio is not properly diversified. On the other hand, a consistently low tracking error can signal a successful strategy that closely aligns with the investor’s objectives. It indicates that the portfolio manager is effectively managing risk and delivering returns that closely match the benchmark.

It is important to note that tracking error is not the only factor to consider when evaluating an investment portfolio. Other factors such as fees, risk tolerance, and investment objectives also play a crucial role. However, understanding tracking error can provide investors with a deeper understanding of how their portfolio is performing relative to the benchmark and help them make more informed investment decisions.

Components of Tracking Error

Tracking error calculations involve several key components that help measure and understand the differences between a portfolio’s performance and its benchmark. Two important components are variance and standard deviation.

Variance and Standard Deviation

Variance is a statistical measure that quantifies the dispersion of returns around the mean return. It provides insights into the extent to which individual returns deviate from the average return. Standard deviation, on the other hand, is the square root of variance and offers a more intuitive measure of risk.

In the context of tracking error, variance and standard deviation are used to assess the differences in returns between the portfolio and the benchmark. A higher variance or standard deviation indicates a larger deviation from the benchmark, suggesting a higher tracking error. This means that the portfolio’s performance is more likely to deviate from the benchmark’s returns.

Portfolio Diversification and Tracking Error

Managing tracking error involves considering various strategies, and one crucial aspect is portfolio diversification. Diversification plays a vital role in reducing the likelihood of extreme deviations from the benchmark’s returns.

By diversifying a portfolio, investors can spread their risk across different asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, and commodities. This approach helps minimize the impact of idiosyncratic factors that may affect the performance of individual assets. Diversification aims to create a more balanced portfolio that is less susceptible to the influence of any single investment or sector.

However, it’s important to note that while diversification can help mitigate tracking error, it may also limit the potential for outperformance. When a portfolio is well-diversified, it may not experience significant deviations from the benchmark, but it may also miss out on opportunities for higher returns. Striking the right balance between diversification and potential outperformance is a decision that investors must carefully consider based on their risk tolerance and investment goals.

In summary, tracking error calculations involve analyzing various components such as variance and standard deviation. These measures help quantify the differences between a portfolio’s performance and its benchmark. Additionally, portfolio diversification plays a crucial role in managing tracking error by reducing the likelihood of extreme deviations from the benchmark’s returns. However, it’s essential to find the right balance between diversification and potential outperformance to align with individual investment objectives.

Calculating Tracking Error

Tracking error is a measure of how closely an investment portfolio tracks its benchmark index. It provides insight into the volatility and risk of the portfolio relative to the benchmark. Calculating tracking error involves several steps:

  1. Collect the monthly returns or other relevant time period returns of the investment portfolio.
  2. Collect the monthly returns of the benchmark index over the same time period.
  3. Calculate the difference between the portfolio returns and the benchmark returns for each period.
  4. Square each difference and sum them up.
  5. Divide the sum by the number of periods.
  6. Take the square root of the result to obtain the tracking error.

Step 1: Collect the Monthly Returns

The first step in calculating tracking error is to gather the monthly returns of the investment portfolio. These returns represent the performance of the portfolio over a specific time period, such as a month. It is important to ensure that the returns are accurately recorded and include any dividends or distributions received during the period.

Step 2: Collect the Benchmark Returns

Next, collect the monthly returns of the benchmark index over the same time period. The benchmark index serves as a reference point for evaluating the performance of the portfolio. It is typically a broad market index that represents the overall market or a specific sector. Examples of benchmark indices include the S&P 500, Dow Jones Industrial Average, or MSCI World Index.

Step 3: Calculate the Difference

Once you have the portfolio returns and benchmark returns, calculate the difference between them for each period. This step involves subtracting the benchmark return from the portfolio return. The difference represents the excess return or underperformance of the portfolio compared to the benchmark.

Step 4: Square and Sum the Differences

To quantify the dispersion of the tracking error, square each difference and sum them up. Squaring the differences ensures that both positive and negative differences contribute to the overall tracking error. Summing up the squared differences provides a measure of the variability between the portfolio returns and the benchmark returns.

Step 5: Divide by the Number of Periods

Divide the sum of squared differences by the number of periods to calculate the average tracking error. This step normalizes the tracking error by accounting for the number of observations. It provides a more meaningful measure of the portfolio’s consistency in tracking the benchmark over time.

Step 6: Take the Square Root

Finally, take the square root of the result obtained in step 5 to obtain the tracking error. The square root operation reverses the squaring process and gives the tracking error in the same units as the returns. A higher tracking error indicates a larger deviation from the benchmark, suggesting higher risk and potential for underperformance.

Common Mistakes in Tracking Error Calculation

When calculating tracking error, it’s important to be mindful of potential pitfalls. One common mistake is using inconsistent time intervals when comparing portfolio returns with benchmark returns. Ensure that the time periods align properly to ensure accurate calculations.

Another common error is failing to adjust for fees and expenses. It’s crucial to include any costs associated with managing the portfolio as they can impact tracking error calculations. These costs may include management fees, transaction costs, and other expenses incurred in the process of maintaining the portfolio.

Impact of Tracking Error on Investment Strategies

Tracking error is a crucial metric that plays a significant role in investment strategies. It measures the divergence between the returns of a portfolio and its benchmark. Understanding the impact of tracking error is essential for both passive and active investors.

Tracking Error and Passive Investing

Passive investment strategies aim to closely replicate the performance of a benchmark. The goal is to achieve returns that are as close as possible to the benchmark’s returns. Therefore, a low tracking error is desirable for passive investors as it indicates that the portfolio accurately mirrors the benchmark’s returns.

Low tracking error suggests a high level of consistency and predictability. This can be appealing for risk-averse investors who prefer a stable and reliable investment approach. By minimizing tracking error, passive investors can have confidence that their portfolio will closely track the benchmark, providing them with a similar level of returns.

Furthermore, low tracking error in passive investing also implies that the portfolio is effectively capturing the broad market movements. This is particularly important for investors who seek broad market exposure without the need for active decision-making.

Tracking Error and Active Investing

Active investment strategies, on the other hand, involve attempting to outperform the benchmark by actively managing the portfolio. Unlike passive investors, active investors aim to generate excess returns beyond the benchmark.

For active investors, a higher tracking error is expected and can be seen as a sign of active management. Since active investors actively make investment decisions, their portfolios are more likely to deviate from the benchmark’s returns. This deviation is reflected in a higher tracking error.

Active investors accept the risk of larger performance deviations in hopes of generating excess returns beyond the benchmark. They believe that their investment expertise and active decision-making can lead to superior performance. A higher tracking error, therefore, signifies that the active investor is taking deliberate steps to differentiate their portfolio from the benchmark.

However, it is important to note that a higher tracking error in active investing also implies a higher level of risk. The potential for larger deviations from the benchmark’s returns means that active investors are exposed to greater volatility and uncertainty. This risk-reward trade-off is a key consideration for investors when deciding between passive and active investment strategies.

In conclusion, tracking error plays a crucial role in investment strategies. For passive investors, a low tracking error is desirable as it indicates a close replication of the benchmark’s returns. On the other hand, active investors expect a higher tracking error as they aim to outperform the benchmark through active management. Understanding the impact of tracking error is essential for investors to make informed decisions and align their investment strategies with their goals and risk tolerance.

Mitigating the Risks of Tracking Error

Effective Risk Management Strategies

To mitigate the risks associated with tracking error, investors can employ several risk management strategies. One such strategy is thorough portfolio oversight and regular rebalancing. By overseeing the portfolio’s composition and periodically realigning it with the desired asset allocation, an investor can aim to maintain the desired tracking error levels.

Additionally, employing risk management techniques, such as using derivatives or hedging strategies, can help reduce the impact of sudden market movements on the portfolio’s returns. Risk management should be tailored to the investor’s risk tolerance, investment horizon, and overall investment strategy.

Role of Financial Advisors in Managing Tracking Error

Financial advisors play a crucial role in assisting investors in managing tracking error. They help formulate investment strategies that align with the investor’s goals and risk tolerance. Financial advisors also provide guidance on asset allocation, portfolio diversification, and selecting appropriate benchmarks.

By working closely with financial advisors, investors can navigate the complexities of tracking error and develop investment approaches that optimize risk-adjusted returns and align with their long-term objectives.

In conclusion, tracking error serves as a valuable metric for investors to assess the risk and efficiency of their investment portfolios. Understanding the components of tracking error, calculating it accurately, and managing its associated risks are essential for successful investment management. By grasping the nuances of tracking error, investors can make informed decisions and maximize their potential for achieving their financial goals.

Scroll to Top

Almost there!

Enter your email below to receive my four free stock trading ebooks with everything you need to start trading the UK stocks.


Get your free stock trading ebooks

Get four free UK stock market ebooks and my monthly trading newsletter with trade ideas and things learned from trading stocks


Don't miss out!

Get four free UK stock market ebooks and my monthly trading newsletter with trade ideas and things learned from trading stocks